Amara Cay Resort, Islamorada
About the Hotel
Amara Cay Resort is situated in the vibrant Florida Keys in Islamorada, known for its picturesque ocean views and rich maritime heritage. The resort combines modern island style with intimate spaces, creating an inviting atmosphere for its guests. With access to a wide range of activities and amenities, it caters uniquely to travelers seeking adventure as well as relaxation. Guests can enjoy the serene surroundings while indulging in the local culture and cuisine.
Location
Amara Cay Resort is centrally located in Islamorada, making it easy to explore the area's attractions and natural beauty. The resort provides access to the Islamorada Resort Collection’s amenities, including multiple beaches and activities. Transportation options include a complimentary shuttle and a water taxi that connects guests to nearby resorts. The on-site marina facilitates boating excursions, enhancing the overall island experience.
Rooms
Accommodations feature coastal chic designs with premium bedding and upscale amenities for a comfortable stay. Options include rooms and suites with private balconies that offer stunning views of the ocean. The furnishings reflect a relaxed island style, enhancing the guest experience with comforts like coffee makers and contemporary bathrooms. Certain rooms provide additional amenities such as kitchenettes and spacious living areas.
Eat & Drink
Dining experiences at Amara Cay highlight Florida Keys' culinary traditions, with options ranging from local seafood to classic American fare. Guests can enjoy casual bites at the poolside Tiki Bar or indulge in elevated dishes at ReelCatch, the on-site restaurant. The menu reflects a blend of island-inspired flavors, and breakfast offerings include grab-and-go selections and hearty meals. Room service is also available for added convenience.
Leisure & Business
The resort offers various leisure amenities, including two pools, a fitness center, and complimentary water sports equipment rentals. For business needs, the Glass Bowl meeting room accommodates small gatherings and corporate events. Guests can also unwind with lawn games or relax by the beach while engaging in resort activities. Additional perks include complimentary parking and a shuttle service within a 6.5 km radius.
Select your room type
Price and Room Availability Calendar
Getting around
A list of all available modes of transport
Facilities
General
- Non-smoking rooms
- Paid Wi-Fi
- Paid parking
- 24-hour reception
- Express check-in/ -out
- Pets allowed
- Rooms/ Facilities for disabled
- Wheelchair access
- Security
- Luggage storage
- Private beach
- Lift
- Smoke detectors
- Electric vehicle charging station
- Key card access
Sports & Fitness
- Fitness centre
- Diving
- Snorkelling
- Cycling
- Golf course
- Fishing
Services
- Free shuttle service
- Pet amenities available
- Room service
- Housekeeping
- Laundry
- Shops/Commercial services
- Welcome drink
Dining
- Restaurant
- Poolside snack bar
- Snack bar
- Special diet menus
Business
- Meeting/ Banquet facilities
- Fax/Photocopying
Children
- Children's menu
Facilities for people with disabilities
- Toilet for disabled
Spa & Leisure
- Heated swimming pool
- Outdoor swimming pool
- Beach access
- Beach umbrellas
- Sun loungers
- Sun terrace
- Garden area
- Leisure/ TV room
- Pool with view
- Shallow end
Room features
- Air conditioning
- Garden furniture
- Tea and coffee facilities
Media
- AM/FM alarm clock
Location
Reviews and Ratings
The hotel is nestled among beautiful palm trees and overlooks a perfect temperature pool. At $1,000 per night, it seems a bit high for my usual budget, but the ambiance is lovely despite an unappealing odor in the rooms.
The hotel room I stayed in had a few issues such as being extremely noisy, making it hard to sleep even with it turned off, and it didn't offer the promised sea view at a rate of USD 200 per night. However, the morning wake-up call was right on time at 7:30, and the staff was friendly.
The hotel offers big and very comfortable rooms with two very good king beds, although the service was mixed with friendly bartenders but lacking in other areas. The location is nice, but some aspects like not having beaches should have been clarified. Dining was excellent, although there was a minor issue with timing. Overall, a good value for money stay.
The hotel's location is nicely redone with very tasteful decor, making it perfect for some cute photos. The rooms felt perfect, featuring an in-wall AC unit and a private terrace, but could have been a little bigger. The service goes above and beyond, with staff even taking us personally in their own car one day. The location is perfect, ideal for a wedding in the area, but had one person taking orders and making drinks with no one attending the pool area. The dining experience, while offering seafood, could be pricey, costing more than a hundred dollars for a meal, and took a while to get to dinner down the street after a recommendation. The facilities are modern and offer luxury amenities, but could use more policing of people holding chairs with umbrellas for hours on the beach with their towels.
I was thrilled with my stay at the hotel. The room didn't quite match the pictures but being on the 5th floor with views of the pool and ocean felt perfect for the price of USD 200 per night. The service stood out as the staff walked around the property to ensure our comfort, always being respectful and with a smile, delivering great hospitality for better service and a pleasant guest experience.
The hotel had its ups and downs. The rooms were a bit more basic than expected, missing essential items like glasses and kitchenware despite booking a suite. They were clean, comfortable, and nicely made, but the noise levels made it challenging to rest. The service was nice and helpful, even going the extra mile for our family, bringing us great joy. The location wasn't very appealing initially, yet the water sports area and pool were nice. However, the additional resort fees made it feel overpriced. The dining experience varied; great for Labor Day weekend but overpriced for everyday dining. The facilities provided were decent, offering enough for a comfortable stay.
